Feedback on Trading System

Fibo Quantum


Feedback on Trading System

Feedback On Trading System

I built a forex trading strategy recently for a friend, and wanted to share it / get some feedback on it, as most of the systems I build trade stocks and are more fundamental/macro based!

Feedback On Trading System

The system was inspired by this forexfactory post: [https://www.forexfactory.com/showthread.php?t=343533](https://www.forexfactory.com/showthread.php?t=343533) but I’ve made a few changes.

Feedback On Trading System

**The Filter:**

Feedback On Trading System

I didn’t like the proposed TMA slope indicator as the calculation and cutoff values seemed too arbitrary to me, so I take the 5 bar ROC of an EMA and smooth it. I divide this value by its standard deviation to scale it for higher timeframe analysis. I take the value of this adjustedSlope at the 4H, 1D, 1W timeframes, and sumproduct them with weights of 40%, 30%, 30% to give a little more strength to recent movements. I call this the overallSlope (for future reference).

Feedback On Trading System

I describe the the market regime under these rules:

Feedback On Trading System

(overallSlope > overallSlope[1] and overallSlope > 0) = bullish

Feedback On Trading System

(overallSlope < overallSlope[1] and overallSlope < 0) = bearish

(overallSlope > overallSlope[1] and overallSlope < 0) = neutral

(overallSlope < overallSlope[1] and overallSlope > 0) = neutral

Just like the system from ForexFactory, only long trades can be taken if its bullish, only short trades can be taken if its bearish, and either trade can be taken if its neutral.

**The Setup:**

I believe this portion is identical to the original stated system. Take the 50 bar Triangular Moving Average on the 4H timeframe, where the UpperBand is TMA + (2.5 * H4ATR) and the LowerBand is TMA – (2.5 * H4ATR).

If the market regime is bullish/neutral and the price has traded below the Lower Band then we’re setting up for a buy and vice versa with a bearish/neutral market regime and price trading above the Upper Band.

I’m considering switching this to Median Absolute Deviation Bands as I like using the modified Z Score but I’m unsure of applying it directly to a price series instead of indirectly through an indicator or factor, I assume the median isn’t very effective due to the actual series drifting, where as its (more) static when applied to Earnings Yield or something.

**The Trigger:**

For the trigger I’m on the 1H TimeFrame using the MACD histogram crossing 0, but the MACD is based on the Jurik Moving Average instead of the standard. A couple years ago when I first started getting into programming and playing forex, the JMA was something I stumbled on and wrote up and I really like it, it’s very effective and smoothing a series, allowing the use of shorter lookback values without the MA being too “jittery”.

**Exits:**

On the losing side, at open a stop loss is placed at (2 * H4ATR) below(above) the low(high) if we’re going Long(Short). I’m currently split between two exits on the profit side. Right now my current exit criteria for a hypothetical long position is a bearish MACD Histogram crossover while we are above the TMA (the “midline”). The other strategy I’m considering is half off at the midline and the other half off at the Upper Band, but I think this isn’t great because it can reverse and hit the stop effectively nulling the trade.

**Risk Management:**

For the risk management of the system I’m using position sizes standardized to risk 3% of the account on each trade by calculating how far away the stop is, and scaling the # of units until $risk = AccVal * .03.

**Additional Comments:**

As of right now I only have it fully coded on TradingView and I’ve made sure to use open prices for everything to avoid? (not sure if this completely handles this issue, please let me know) lookahead bias and I’m in the process of translating my code into my backtesting system but a lot of what I’ve built is equity related so I have some work to do to get it running right for forex. In TradingView I have it plot the Entry, Stop, and two targets, and the background shifts based on if it’s long/short/flat. [https://imgur.com/a/A1UQi04](https://imgur.com/a/A1UQi04)

I look forward to any thoughts or comments y’all may have, thanks for reading!



View Reddit by ilovemygirlfriend69View Source

About The Author

You might be interested in

Comment (2)

  1. I am testing a similar strategy, based on the same FF thread. For the slope, I’ve tried using the TmaSlopeTrue that was provided on that thread, and I’ve also used an MA of a Roc of an SMA.
    However I used 2.0 atr like the thread suggested, the 2.5 was initially only for the M15 TF.
    Haven’t had too much of a success backtesting it, the WR is too low. How did yours fare regarding backtesting?

    View Comment

LEAVE YOUR COMMENT

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Feedback on Trading System

Stop, wait one minute!

You Win absolutely free of charge unique software which will increase probability of your profitable tradings up to 85%. This system costs 297$ and this free offer is limited!

Thank's for subscription! Please check your email and download the software!